second calendar year: May

Last update of this page: 10-10-05 06:20

The variation in moult strategies within the LBBG-complex is nearly larger than the inter-specific variation in moult strategies between most other European large gull-taxa.
To a certain extent this has been caused by intra-specific differences in the geographical position of the winter-quarters. Concerning first summer LBBGs, several authors highlighted the different moult strategies between fuscus / heuglini and their western relatives graellsii / intermedius in recent publications.
However, the articles were written on the assumption that intermedius and graellsii share a similar moult strategy. Without questioning the importance of these publications, we think the latter is a (too) simplified approach.
On the basis of concise descriptions and photographs of a few representative individuals, we would like to give an impression of our observations made over the last few years.

Currently, we recognize at least three types of 1st-summer LBBGs, which occur in large numbers (up to 60 individuals daily) on migration during spring and early summer at the Maasvlakte, the Netherlands (51.58 N, 4.02 E). Birds with intermediate characteristics are certainly not rare, but at least a considerable part is distinguishable.
Anyhow, we would like to stress that our classification has mainly been based on the differences in plumage patterning or moult-timing.

first type

From the few ring-recoveries from England and the Netherlands, we could say that Dutch 1st summer LBBGs born at the Maasvlakte don't differ much from the English same-aged graellsii.
Normally, the scapulars and mantle feathers have a pale or greyish base with brown anchors or barring. The wing-coverts are usually completely juvenile or juvenile with only a small number of 2nd generation coverts. The tail is largely black-brown and nearly always juvenile (or at most a 2nd generation R1). The under-parts and head are patterned with bold markings on a dirty base. The bill is mostly blackish, with only a slightly paler base. Legs are pink.
Nevertheless, in spring 2000 one Belgian colour-ringed individual showed a suspended covert-moult process with 4 2nd generation greater coverts, complete 2nd generation tertials, 8 2nd generation median coverts and approximately the same number of 2nd generation lesser coverts.

The first birds with active primary-moult in the inner primaries appear in the last week of April (generally in NW France) and in the first week of May at Maasvlakte, the Netherlands. Towards the end of the month, the number of birds in active primary moult steadily grows. From the beginning of June it is hard to find any individual which has not shed any primary yet.
The quality of remaining juvenile primaries in spring is usually low, caused by heavy bleaching and wear. The contrast between new and old primaries is very obvious.

second and third type

Regarding both types:
We believe 'core-representatives' of the 2nd and 3rd type are morphologically different from 'core-first types' and probably belong to intermedius-populations. They show a short neck, small rounded head, fine and short bill, short legs (especially tibia) creating a delicate and compact appearance. In some individuals this is pronounced by the relatively short primary-projection. Also, plumage and the timing of moult in wing-coverts and tail-feathers are on average different from the first type.
At first we would like to treat wing-covert, tail and primary moult in general.

Tail-feather moult
The number of moulted tail-feathers in the winter-quarters is highly variable and subsequently we find large variation in May and June. Advanced individuals show a complete 2nd generation tail, while others return with a clearly suspended moult-stage. In the winter-quarters, many individuals do not proceed the moult of the rectrices in a descendant sequence, since migrating birds in spring really show every conceivable moult-stage (e.g. R5-6 2nd generation, while R1-4 are still juvenile, etc).
Some birds do not show fully-grown rectrices, but it is at least not usual to find a tail in active moult by May and the first half of June. Apart from the obvious fresh white tips, the pattern of the 2nd generation rectrices is mostly juvenile-like, but the darker parts are pure black and the pattern is more vermiculated. However, birds with for example a partially white R2, a nearly complete black R3 and with a R4 showing much white, are common. A small minority shows only very little black on the 2nd generation tail-feathers.
The renewed upper-tail coverts are completely white or with some sparse barring on a white base.

Wing-covert moult
The wing-covert moult has mainly been suspended prior to migration, with in most cases a generation contrast between the inner and outer coverts. This especially applies to the greater coverts, which often show a mix of juvenile and 2nd generation coverts, together with tertials and median coverts which have been renewed. The moult-stage of lesser coverts is more advanced than in the greater coverts, but especially 'upper' lesser coverts are less advanced than the tertials and median coverts.
Regarding the under-wing coverts and axillaries; it is often very difficult to obtain good views to determine the generation. In advanced individuals, these under-wing coverts are already partially or completely renewed and sometimes nearly all-white. It might turn out that the moult of under-wing coverts and coverts show similarity in moult strategy.

Primary moult
The onset of the primary moult in 2nd and 3rd type 2cy LBBGs in early summer is on average slightly later (1-2 weeks) than in typical 1st types. Additionally, the individual variation is more pronounced, with e.g. in the 3rd week of June, birds with only P1-2 missing and birds which already shed P7. However, in comparison with the first type, differences in timing of primary moult is usually not significant.
An interesting phenomenon we encountered, was the sometimes remarkably good condition of the remaining juvenile primaries. In a few cases we experienced real difficulties in determining the generation of the primaries.

Variation in the second type
In short we will discuss the general variation of the 2nd type and its difference from the 1st and 3rd type.

Compared with the first type we already stated that both second and third type usually return to the breeding grounds (northern feeding grounds) with some renewed wing-coverts, tertials and even regularly rectrices. Besides other differences from the first type already covered under the header 'regarding both types', juvenile tail-feathers in this type show less blackish brown patterning on the base of the tail-feathers, causing a less broad but more contrasting tail-band.
Even the under-parts are paler in the second type, with contrasting spots mainly restricted to the flanks and lower hind-neck. The palest parts are the breast and head.  

In comparison with the 3rd type the under-parts are slightly more patterned, especially on the flanks and hind-neck. The 2nd generation upper-parts and wing-coverts show obvious barring and anchor-patterns on a pale or cold brownish grey centre, surrounded by a pale fringe in the second type. The tertials show contrastingly bold brown or blackish barring on a white base (see photo 10 and 11) or only a blackish brown base with a sub-terminal bar sharply demarcated from the pale tip (like third type birds).
Moult-stage and even pattern of renewed feather tracts are on average less advanced than in the third type. The upper-parts seem to be moulted in an earlier stage than the wing-coverts, resulting in a 'wear contrast' between fresher coverts/ tertials against heavier worn scapulars and mantle feathers.

General information regarding the third type and its difference from typical fuscus:
Our knowledge of fuscus is confined to published photographs and limited field observations, but there is little doubt that 3rd types may resemble fuscus superficially. However, we have good reasons to believe this type belongs to intermedius rather than fuscus. To name a few:

1. We have seen every conceivable moult stage (0-100%) in coverts, tertials and tail feathers.
2. Although less often, comparable advanced moult stages occur in the 2nd type.
3. Returning birds with completely or partially moulted primaries (suspended) are very rare.
4. Migration started from the beginning of May onwards, which is too early for fuscus (arriving by July). The latter taxon only rarely reaches northern latitudes in May.

Even if there appears to be intermediate characters, it remains unlikely that birds of this type are a result of hybridisation between both taxa. One would at least expect less high numbers on migration.

As stated earlier, we only have limited experience with fuscus. Based on photographs in various magazines, we think that on colour and pattern of plumage alone, some individuals are hard to separate from typical fuscus. We feel that mahogany brown colours in coverts and tertials are rare in typical 3rd types. In individuals with freshly moulted coverts, the pattern we most often see is a blackish central wedge on a grey brown base, broadening towards the tip, with near the tip some white. Another common pattern is just a diffuse dark shaft on a grey-brown base, and normally with some white near the tip. But remember that patterns may become indistinct or even undetectable when feathers become heavily worn and abraded.

In many birds, the mantle and wing-coverts have been replaced in one wave and in such a case lack any 'wear contrast'. This sometimes results in an already worn and bleached 2nd generation bird.
As shown in the images, typical 3rd types are quite easy to separate from typical 2nd types on plumage colouration and pattern alone. The under-parts are clean white, with only  contrasting spots on hind-neck and flanks. Like the second type, this type shows a paler bill-base. A few birds already have a pale-yellow bill-base. Pale yellow legs have also been noticed in this type, but surely not often.

Other types

Except for these three recognizable types, individuals with serious characteristics of fuscus or with serious characteristics of heuglini turn up in the Netherlands during spring and early summer. Although we call these types simply fuscus-types respectively heuglini-types, this is without the intention of treating these birds as true representatives of both taxa.
It is possible that both types are aberrant individuals from the third or (less probable) second type as discussed above. Lars Jonsson, in his article about identification of fuscus LBBGs (Birding World, 1998) states: "probably the most obvious option is to look for first-summer birds with a new set of flight feathers in July-August." Some of these birds match this feature, as can be seen in image 18.

First type
LBBG V049 April 10 - May 10 2009, Madrid, Spain. Pictures: Delfín González & Javier Marchamalo.
LBBG H513 April & May 2008, Ciudad Real, Spain. Picture: Gabriel Martín.
Photo 1: LBBG 2cy, May 25 2000, Maasvlakte, the  Netherlands.
Photo 2a: LBBG 2cy, May 11 2001, Naaktstrand Maasvlakte, the Netherlands.
2cymay0219.jpg (98540 bytes)Photo 2b: LBBG 2cy, May 13 2002, Missouriweg, Maasvlakte, the Netherlands.
Photo 3: LBBG 2cy, May 18 2000, Maasvlakte, the Netherlands.
Photo 4: 1st type LBBG 2cy, May 26 2000 Maasvlakte (Dintelhaven), the Netherlands. 
2cy704.jpg (70836 bytes)Photo 5: LBBG 2cy, May 23 2002, Missouriweg Maasvlakte, the Netherlands.
Photo 6: LBBG 2cy, May 12 2001, Missouriweg Maasvlakte, the Netherlands.
Photo 7: LBBG 2cy, May 11 2001, Naaktstrand Maasvlakte, the Netherlands.
Photo 8: LBBG 2cy, May 4 2001, Le Portel (France).
2cy763.jpg (73991 bytes)Photo 8a: LBBG 2cy, May 23 2002, Vuurtorenvlakte - Maasvlakte, the Netherlands.
2cy879.jpg (60303 bytes)Photo 8b: LBBG 2cy, May 31 2002, Papegaaienbek - Maasvlakte, the Netherlands. Not particularly barred in the scapulars but otherwise very reminiscent of local Dutch 2cy LBBG.
2cylbbg868.jpg (49877 bytes)Photo 8c: LBBG 2cy, May 31 2002, Papegaaienbek - Maasvlakte, the Netherlands. Note the anchor pattern in the scapulars.
second type

Photo 9: LBBG 2cy, May 4 2001, Le Portel (France).

Photo 10 : 2nd type LBBG 2cy, May 2000, Maasvlakte, the Netherlands.
Photo 11: 2nd type LBBG 2cy, May 25 2000, Maasvlakte, the Netherlands.
Photo 12: LBBG 2cy, May 6 2001, Dannes (France).

Photo 13: LBBG 2cy, May 4 2001, Le Portel (France).

Photo 14: LBBG 2cy, May 5 2001, Etaples (France). The most advanced individual.
third type

Photo 15: LBBG 2cy, May 11 2001, Naaktstrand Maasvlakte, the Netherlands.

Photo 16: 3rd-type LBBG 2cy, May 25 2000, Maasvlakte, the Netherlands.
Photo 17: 3rd type LBBG 2cy, May 29 2000 Maasvlakte, the Netherlands. 
Other types
Photo 18: fuscus-type LBBG 2cy, May 29 2000.
Maasvlakte, the  Netherlands.